2 Rejected samples
I have had two samples rejected.
The first rejection said "there is hiss." I couldn't hear any, and I had others review the sample- they agreed.
The second, submitted yesterday, was rejected due to Room Echo. I can't hear any in this sample, and if you saw the studio I'm using (professionally built, completely acoustically dead) you would see that this makes no sense.
Reading other forum entries, it appears that whatever computer algorithm you're using to judge these samples is prone to error. Is it possible to have an actual human listen to my samples, and provide real, usable feedback?
I am unable to find the samples I've submitted on your website- it appears I don't have access. Other forum contributors post links to their samples- I would like to do this but do not know how.
Thank you,
Frank Shaw
Please sign in to leave a comment.
Hello Frank
https://voicebunny.com/projects/5ce1fe6ac6cdb-application-project-for-frank-shaw That first application project has a lot of white noise that's particularly noticeable when you speak (at the beginning and end of your words). Perhaps with a pair of headphones you'll be able to notice it more clearly.
Regarding the last rejection https://voicebunny.com/projects/5cfd9d85d4a0f-application-project-for-frank-shaw I do not agree with the reverberation remark, however, I believe the white noise is still there. The plugin that you're using will not get rid of that noise effectively. Perhaps you're giving it too much gain to your preamp when recording, or you're using gear that increases the amount of noise in the recording.
Hope that helps.
Oscar
Hi Oscar,
Yes, this is very helpful. I was listening in the wrong place. I am resetting my gain structure and will try again. It's nice to be working with a human being. Thanks for your help!
Frank
You're welcome, Frank.
Anything we can help you with, just let us know.
Once you're ready to share with us a new file, please do so.
Best,
Oscar
Oscar,
I've done some work in my studio, and I think I've addressed the issue you mentioned. I'd like to resubmit this audition if possible:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/ltyv4a790s3di1h/Bunny%202A.wav?dl=0
In any case, can you give it a listen and let me know if you think it's improved?
Thank you,
Frank Shaw
I'm still picking up some hiss noise, Frank.
It might be due to a faulty wire or connection. May we know which gear you're using to record?
Signal path is as follows:
SM7B - Cloudlifter CL1 - DBX 286s - Focusrite Scarlett Solo 2nd gen - Apple MAC Mini 2019.
Recently I removed all other equipment from the signal path, made certain all mic cables were high quality and as short as possible. I even moved the Cloudlifter onto the mic boom to get it as close as possible to the mic. I tested all the cables; no faults, shorts, or intermittent connections. I've changed to a close-mic technique to provide the highest signal-to-noise at the front end, and carefully set the gain structure at each stage. I've also tried recording without the Cloudlifter, as the DBX has just barely enough gain for the SM& by itself. Those tests sounded noisier to me, so I kept the Cloudlifter. Any equipment reccommendadtions you may have are welcome.
It's clear your hearing is better than mine (no surprise given my age and time in loud environments,) so along with whatever technical suggestions you have, could you please answer a couple of questions: 1. Has the "hiss" improved from the previous recording? 2. What is your best estimate of the frequency band of the "hiss?" 3. What is the maximim acceptable noise floor?
It's nice to have professional help on this, I appreciate it. Thank you Oscar.
Perhaps it is the SM7B because it is intended for live environments as it is a dynamic mic...
Let me answer your questions:
1. I believe it has improved.
2. I couldn't actually tell you as I was analyzing the file in logic and it seems to be a very broad spectrum. It might be better to try changing one of the elements of your recording chain (for instance the ATH 2035 has worked for many people in the platform)
3. 60dBSPL or less for noise floor would work
Oscar,
Try this take: https://www.dropbox.com/s/3ckopa5ir1irsgu/Bunny%20Three.wav?dl=0
I borrowed a condenser mic. please let me know if this is improved.
Thanks,
Frank
Hi Frank
I think it has improved. I was not able to notice the hiss this time. Perhaps what was creating an issue was the mic?
Just some sound clips at the ends of some parts here and there (ex. 0:10, 0:17) that can be polished by editing a bit softer the endings and beginnings of the phrases.
Great job, sir!
Thanks for the help. I will clean up the edits. What do I need to do to resubmit?
Perfect, Frank.
Here you'll find the instructions on how to submit a reconsideration request https://help.bunnyinc.com/hc/en-us/articles/360002587679-How-many-chances-do-I-get-at-auditioning-to-become-a-Pro-
Best of luck!